Owing it's name to the 14th largest tree in the world, Redwood Empire Pipe Dream Bourbon comes very close to making the top 5 list.  This was probably the least-known bottle in the lineup that was tested but is one you should keep a look out for.  Redwood blends barrels from 4-12 years old to create this and then ages it in the temperate climate of Northern California.  We often hear about the four distinct seasons of Kentucky being an advantage to aging whiskey as it increases the barrel and whiskey interaction, and therefore the flavor.  It'll be interesting to see how a more consistent aging climate will impact this bourbon, as well as, a lower (90) proof point.  On paper, you would think it will be a bit light and not much flavor.  

Stats: NAS (blend of 4-12 yr barrels); 75% corn, 21% rye, 4% malted barley; 90 proof; $36

Verdict: Well, that's why they play the game so to speak.  While on paper it would seem like there's not much flavor to it but that is not the case here.  You're not going to find an overly complex profile but what it does, it does well.  The first thing I notice is the earthy nose it presents.  The palate offers an initial flavor of corn, reminiscent of a buttery cornbread. There's also a nuttiness to it and the oak flavor is more toasted than a charred oak.  Hints of caramel and vanilla play in the background and give way to a mild but pleasant finish.  If you're in need of an "everyday" bourbon, this is it.  The price, the proof, and the profile are perfect for that.  The buttery smooth bread forward profile is not uncommon but a bit of a side street compared to the busy highway of oak and vanilla heavy profiles in many bottles in this category.  This would be a great gift bottle for most bourbon drinkers, especially those newer to exploring the whiskey world as it's probably something they haven't tried but will thoroughly enjoy.  It should be one that challenges thoughts of "only good bourbon comes from the big-6 producers."  Lack of complexity keeps it out of the top 5 but this is a very, very good bourbon!